
According to the
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee Guidebook…
There is
increasing public interest in exploring alternatives to the use of
animals in biological research and testing. IACUCs regularly
consider the question, "Is
there an alternative to using live animals in this proposal?" Some
suggest that the only acceptable alternatives are those that
completely replace animals, while others have less restrictive
definitions. The definition of alternatives that allows
a degree of common understanding was developed by Russell
and Burch, and is referred to as the three "Rs"- replacement,
refinement, and reduction. For
this discussion, the term "alternatives" refers to systems
that do not employ whole live animals.
Alternatives
to the use of animals include in vitro model systems. For
example, isolated organ preparations, such as the perfused heart,
represent in vitro models. More commonly, in vitro systems
are thought of as cell, tissue and organ cultures. The source
of the tissue may be primary tissue or cell lines obtained invasively
or non-invasively. Tests have been developed using in vitro systems
for the evaluation of cytotoxicity, inflammation, genotoxicity,
and target organ toxicity among others. A third alterative is
the use of nonbiological models systems. These include chemically-based
systems, physical models such as hemodynamic flow chambers or
computer simulations. More mechanistic
models are being developed such as quantitative structure-activity
responses, linear modeling relationships, and three dimensional
computation models. As more data become available, an expansion
in this area is anticipated.
Listed below
are helpful resources that provide additional information on alternatives:
AGRICOLA
AGRICultural OnLine Access: Bibliographic database of citations to
publications and resources encompassing all aspects of agriculture and
allied disciplines, including animal and veterinary sciences,
entomology, plant sciences, forestry, aquaculture and fisheries,
farming and farming systems, agricultural economics, extension and
education, food and human nutrition, and earth and environmental
sciences. Coverage 1970-present.
Altweb (Johns Hopkins)
Provides a search engine to find information on alternative
procedures.
Center for Animal Alternatives (UC-Davis)
CRISP Computer
Retrieval of Information on Scientific Project: Contains research
projects supported by the PHS, NIH, NIMH, NIAA. Includes current and
past projects. Coverage 1972-present.
PubMed
Citations and abstracts for articles published in journals in
medicine, life science and health administrations.
NAL
Animals Use Alternatives Thesaurus Produced by the US National
Agricultural Library, this site provides a classification of
terminology relating to alternatives and animal welfare.
TOXLINE National Library on Medicine's extensive collection of
online bibliographic information covering the biochemical,
pharmacological, physiological, and toxicological effects of drugs and
other chemicals. |